Jewelry Worth Money: How to Tell
Jewelry is valuable when its metal, stones, and weight of precious metal add up, not just because it’s old or has “silver” on a tag. That is the first confusion to clear up before asking whether an inherited piece, or one you no longer wear, is worth selling. A professional appraisal, simple and free, lets you know for certain.
Key Takeaways
- Jewelry worth money combines several factors: the metal, the gemstones, and the actual weight of precious metal
- Home tests never give a reliable value
- Hallmarking is governed by Canadian federal law
- An appraisal at Bijouterie Claude Filion is free and comes with no obligation to buy
What Makes a Piece of Jewelry Truly Valuable
The value of a piece of jewelry depends on three factors that work together: the type of metal, the presence of gemstones, and the actual weight of precious metal it contains. An old piece made of base metal is worth no more than a similar recent one, while a recent piece in solid gold can be worth far more than a hundred-year-old piece with no precious content.
The Metal: Gold, Silver, and Platinum
Gold, silver, and platinum are the three most common precious metals in jewelry, each with its purity scale. Gold is measured in karats, from 9K to 24K under Canadian regulations, while sterling silver generally bears the 925 mark, for 925 parts per thousand of pure silver. The higher the fineness, the greater the share of precious metal in the piece, and the higher its resale value.
Gemstones and Their Certification
A diamond, ruby, or sapphire can account for a significant share of a piece’s total value, sometimes more than the metal that holds it. The size, color, and clarity of the stone affect its price, but only an examination by a properly equipped professional can assess them accurately. An uncertified stone is not necessarily worthless; it simply needs an expert eye to be judged.
The Actual Weight of Precious Metal
The weight of the gold, silver, or platinum in a piece of jewelry directly determines its resale value, regardless of its age. A piece’s age does not automatically increase its value: that is a widespread myth. A heavier or finer piece is usually worth more than a lighter one, even if the lighter one is older.
Why Home Tests Are Not Enough
The magnet test, or the bite test, gives, at best, an indication, never a reliable value. These common methods cannot measure the exact fineness of a metal, assess a stone, or guarantee a fair transaction. According to Measurement Canada, the weight of a piece of jewelry is only one factor among others in determining its value. The other factors, notably the exact nature of the stones and the precise fineness of the metal, require the trained eye of a professional to be assessed correctly.
The amount of precious metal in a piece of jewelry is also governed by law. In Canada, the Precious Metals Marking Act requires that a quality mark truly and correctly indicate the fineness of the metal, according to precise standards for gold, silver, platinum, or palladium. Reading a hallmark correctly requires knowing this regulation, which a jeweler does every day and has done for years.
An old or handmade piece may lack a legible hallmark, either due to wear or because it was never applied. In that case, the jeweler’s expertise takes over: purity tests carried out in store make it possible to determine the exact fineness of the metal, even without a visible quality mark.
How to Get a Reliable Appraisal in Saint-Eustache
The only way to know the real value of a piece of jewelry is to have it appraised in person by a properly equipped professional. Bijouterie Claude Filion has practiced this trade for over 65 years in the Lower Laurentians, with expertise built on more than a hundred projects completed each month in its workshop.
A Measurement Canada–Certified Scale
The scales used to weigh gold or other precious metals must be approved and inspected by Measurement Canada, specifically designed for this type of weighing and compliant with the accuracy requirements of the Weights and Measures Act. This certification guarantees an accurate weighing and a fair transaction, unlike a home estimate.
A Free Appraisal With No Obligation
The in-store appraisal takes place on site, without an appointment, and takes only a few minutes. It is free and commits you to nothing: you remain free to keep your jewelry after learning its value or to receive a cash payment if you decide to sell.
Visit the Store for a Free Appraisal
The real value of a piece of jewelry is only revealed once it has been examined by an expert eye. Bijouterie Claude Filion welcomes you in Saint-Eustache for a free, no-obligation appraisal, with a Measurement Canada–certified scale and more than 65 years of experience in jewelry and gold buying. Visit the store to find out what your jewelry is really worth today.
FAQ: Jewelry Worth Money, Your Questions
How can I tell whether a piece of jewelry has value without bringing it to the store?
-
You can spot certain clues with the naked eye, such as a hallmark or an unusual weight, but these clues never give a reliable value. Only a professional appraisal with a certified scale can establish the real value of a piece of jewelry.
Is 925 silver jewelry worth anything when resold?
-
Yes, 925 sterling silver is a precious metal that jewelry stores buy, although its value by weight is generally lower than that of gold. The 925 hallmark makes it easier to identify during the appraisal.
Does the age of a piece of jewelry automatically increase its value?
-
No. Age alone guarantees nothing: it is the combination of metal, stones, and actual weight of precious metal that determines a piece’s value, not the mere number of years.
How long does an in-store appraisal take?
-
An appraisal is generally done in a few minutes, on site, with no appointment needed at Bijouterie Claude Filion.
Should I clean my jewelry before bringing it in for an appraisal?
-
No, that is not necessary. An experienced jeweler assesses the metal and stones as they are, and cleaning has no effect on the result of the appraisal.
What if my jewelry contains gemstones?
-
The stones are assessed separately from the metal during the in-store visit. Some stones can add significant value to a piece, to be confirmed directly on site.
Does the appraisal commit me to selling my jewelry?
-
No, the appraisal is free and without obligation. You remain free to keep your jewelry after learning its estimated value.